-->

Tuesday, August 22, 2006

 

Knock-down versus knock-out

In boxing, there is a big difference between a knock-down and a knock-out. A knock-out is an automatic victory.

The Canadian Association of Internet Providers has a self-governing policy that knocks down websites that contain potentially illegal content, or content that contravenes the ISP's acceptable use policy. The Canadian ISP believes it has done good, because it no longer collects $20 per month in hosting fees and it claims that it is contributing to a better world. But in fact, the internet is no safer from these exercises.

Like boxing, knocking down is only a temporary inconvenience. The website re-appears soon, hosted on another ISP, often outside of Canada.

Look at the case of Dossier Noir, a white-supremacist Quebec website that was knocked down, only to reappear in the US, darker and more dangerous. The CBC writes about the site, noting
A racist website that shut down Sunday night after a complaint to the Canadian Human Rights Commission returned to the internet less than a day later in a more vitriolic form.
What I think is needed is to block access to the site. If the content is offensive enough that an ISP will knock it off their servers, then knock it out completely. Finish the job.

Technorati Tags:
, , , , , ,


Comments:
ISP Content filtering is a slippery slope. Once you start blocking access/content at the ISP level, you could open the doors to being always accountable for managing the acceptability of the content. ISPs have traditionally only been blind networks, which left the legality of deciding what is acceptable and what is not to the legal systems. I would be surprised if ISPs took on the responsibility of censorship on the internet.

Don't get me wrong, I'm all for removing annything that promotes hate, abuse, or racism, but I'm not convinced it should be the responsibility of the ISP to determine it.
 
The ISP is Google -- specifically, Google's blooger.com. Are you going to IP ban Google? LOL
 
Free speech is great, but it isn't all encompassing. There are laws against hate speech, plain and simple. Newspapers can't print it, why should ISPs be allowed to serve it?

Why would it be surprising for ISPs to take responsibility for internet censorship? As described in this post, they are already knocking down illegal content. Why not go one step further and knock it out?

Explained during a session entitled "Illegal Content on the Internet" at the 2006 Canadian Telecom Summit, technology is evolving much faster than the laws that govern it. Those who develop new technologies should be responsible for evaluating how it can be abused, AND taking measures to prevent such abuse.

Most view the internet as a locale in which anything can be done without consequence: illegal file sharing, child pornography, hate speech. This needs to change, and those who seem to be the most capable of enforcing this change are the ISPs.
 
This has nothing to do with free speech and everything to do with plain old criminal activity. ISPs should not be in the business of permitting their service to be used by the likes of this Nazi to counsel the murder of an individual. Congrats to Mark , CJC and Richard Warman for going after this person. He is nothing but a common criminal in my books.
 
I must admit to being torn by this one but on balance I have to agree with o"Hara. I would reject outright any attempt at censoring speech even vile hate speech. However on this one advocating the murder of someone crosses every line imaginable.
 
A friend directed me to this interesting discussion. The issue that worries many civil libertarians is the "slippery slope" argument. And to be sure if we were discussing free speech the argument would be a valid one.

However, as pointed out by others the free speech issue becomes moot when extremists use the internet to counsel or promote the murder of fellow human beings.

As a civil libertarian myself my line in the sand is drawn by the criminal actions of people like Bill White. In a free and democratic society the anarchy of propogating murder cannot be tolerated.

Richard Warman whom I dont always agree with is in this case to be commended.Together with Mr. Goldberg and the Jewish Congress they are taking a stand in defence of democracy against individuals who feel they can wantonly issue warrants of murder.
 
Unless you're wow gold and wow gold a Warlock or a Paladin, purchasing a mount at level 40 can be cheap wow gold and cheap wow gold a near impossible thing to buy wow gold and buy wow gold afford. Without world of warcraft gold and world of warcraft gold the honored faction discount, the cost cheapest wow gold,cheap world of warcraft gold is 100gp; 20gp to pay buy world of warcraft gold for the training fast wow gold and 80 to fast wow gold pay for the mount buy cheap wow gold itself. Even cheapest world of warcraft gold with the 10% discount, the wow gold for sale cost gold for wow of 90gp is staggering to players at sell wow gold such low levels. This is aoc gold on-top of the heavy training costs aoc gold,cheap aoc gold for level 40 spells and abilities cheap aoc gold,buy aoc gold which easily cost over buy aoc gold 1gp each to learn! The level 40 ffxi gil mark in the game is easily one ffxi gil of the most expensive levels in buy ffxi gil the game.

At level 40, Hunters buy ffxi gil and Shamans learn to wear cheap ffxi gil chainmail armor. Thus, on top cheap ffxi gil of the wide range of wow power leveling,wow powerleveling spells and abilities wow power leveling earned at that level, and the ability wow powerleveling to ride a mount, they have power leveling to purchase a powerleveling whole new world of warcraft power leveling set of armor. Warriors and Paladins world of warcraft powerleveling go through the world of warcraft powerleveling same ordeal, upgrading wow power level from chainmail to platemail. For other wow power level classes like Priests, Mages and Rogues, level wow powerlevel,power leveling 40 represents a whole new selection of skills and spells which ffxi power leveling can cost over 20gp to afford them aoc power leveling all. All these expenditures while the player is rs power leveling still getting 5-10 silver pieces per kill! The costs wow powerlevel only keep piling up as you progress in levels, making gold world of warcraft power leveling farming one of the most arduous and boring tasks a player is challenged with.,wow leveling wow leveling

Druids are rs gold the blessed servants of buy rs gold Cenarion and cheap rs gold protectors of the natural order swg credits of the Azeroth. Their powers swg gold spring from the buy swg credits very energy of the cheap swg credits world itself and allow Druid lotro gold characters buy lotro gold to tap into nature's raw cheap lotro gold power to silkroad gold transform themselves buy silkroad gold into fearsome cheap silkroad gold creatures, attack guild wars gold opponents with buy guild wars gold mystic cheap guild wars gold energy, or heal gw gold and buff their anarchy gold allies. Druids buy anarchy gold are welcome cheap anarchy gold in almost any ao gold group, able buy ao gold to perform cheap ao gold multiple roles gaiaonline gold as the need gaia gold arises. For gold on gaia the Alliance, cheap gaia gold only Night gaia gold fast Elves buy gaia gold may become gaia online gold Druids. Knightonline gold Having abandoned ko gold the practices tibia gold of arcane magic buy tibia gold which caused the cheap tibia gold downfall rf gold of their brethren, the buy rf gold Blood cheap rf gold Elves, the Night vanguard gold Elves cheap vanguard gold have become buy vanguard gold masters vanguard soh gold of nature. For the soh gold Horde, only buy soh gold the shamanistic cheap soh gold Tauren have cov infamy the capacity buy cov infamy of becoming cheap cov infamy Druids.

The difference cov gold between the cabal alz two races is buy cabal alz slight; a Night Elf cheap cabal alz transforms into a cabal gold Black Panther for shaiya gold their buy shaiya gold combat form, while cheap shaiya gold as a Tauren becomes ddo plat a Lion. No matter buy ddo plat which side your cheap ddo plat character ddo gold may be on, you will buy ddo gold find Druids to cheap ddo gold be one of the 2moons dil most capable 2 moons dil classes in PVP buy 2moons dil and PVE. Shrugging cheap 2moons dil off 2moons gold polymorphs, removing 2 moons gold curses and breaking buy 2moons gold any movement cheap 2moons gold afflictions, Druids dofus kamas are a buy dofus kamas terror on any cheap dofus kamas PVP buying dofus kamas battlefield. At dofus gold higher levels, Druids are buy dofus gold primarily healers, becoming cheap dofus gold an essential part archlord gold to 40-man raid groups archlord online gold seeking to buy archlord gold kill dragons cheap archlord gold and gods ultima online gold in the depths of uo gold Azeroth's most buy ultima online gold dangerous uogold dungeons. No buy uo gold guild looking to sof gold kill Ragnaros, the soldier of fortune gold Lord of Fire, or sof 2 gold Nefarion, ruler of Black sof ii gold Rock Mountain, is buy sof gold complete without Druids cheap sof gold in their ranks. We can help you get there.
 
Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?